• strict warning: Declaration of FeedsImporter::copy() should be compatible with FeedsConfigurable::copy(FeedsConfigurable $configurable) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/feeds/includes/FeedsImporter.inc on line 94.
  • strict warning: Declaration of FeedsNodeProcessor::map() should be compatible with FeedsProcessor::map($source_item, $target_item = NULL) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/feeds/plugins/FeedsNodeProcessor.inc on line 319.
  • strict warning: Declaration of FeedsNodeProcessor::setTargetElement() should be compatible with FeedsProcessor::setTargetElement(&$target_item, $target_element, $value) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/feeds/plugins/FeedsNodeProcessor.inc on line 319.
  • strict warning: Declaration of FeedsFeedNodeProcessor::map() should be compatible with FeedsProcessor::map($source_item, $target_item = NULL) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/feeds/plugins/FeedsFeedNodeProcessor.inc on line 227.
  • strict warning: Declaration of FeedsFeedNodeProcessor::setTargetElement() should be compatible with FeedsProcessor::setTargetElement(&$target_item, $target_element, $value) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/feeds/plugins/FeedsFeedNodeProcessor.inc on line 227.
  • strict warning: Declaration of FeedsUserProcessor::map() should be compatible with FeedsProcessor::map($source_item, $target_item = NULL) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/feeds/plugins/FeedsUserProcessor.inc on line 195.
  • warning: preg_replace(): Compilation failed: disallowed Unicode code point (>= 0xd800 && <= 0xdfff) at offset 1809 in /home/writezil/public_html/modules/search/search.module on line 334.
  • warning: preg_replace(): Compilation failed: disallowed Unicode code point (>= 0xd800 && <= 0xdfff) at offset 1809 in /home/writezil/public_html/modules/search/search.module on line 334.
  • warning: preg_replace(): Compilation failed: disallowed Unicode code point (>= 0xd800 && <= 0xdfff) at offset 1809 in /home/writezil/public_html/modules/search/search.module on line 334.
  • warning: preg_replace(): Compilation failed: disallowed Unicode code point (>= 0xd800 && <= 0xdfff) at offset 1809 in /home/writezil/public_html/modules/search/search.module on line 334.
  • warning: preg_replace(): Compilation failed: disallowed Unicode code point (>= 0xd800 && <= 0xdfff) at offset 1809 in /home/writezil/public_html/modules/search/search.module on line 334.
  • warning: preg_replace(): Compilation failed: disallowed Unicode code point (>= 0xd800 && <= 0xdfff) at offset 1809 in /home/writezil/public_html/modules/search/search.module on line 334.
  • You must include at least one positive keyword with 3 characters or more.
  • strict warning: Non-static method view::load() should not be called statically in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/views.module on line 843.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_plugin_display::options_validate() should be compatible with views_plugin::options_validate(&$form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/plugins/views_plugin_display.inc on line 1877.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_plugin_display_block::options_submit() should be compatible with views_plugin_display::options_submit(&$form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/plugins/views_plugin_display_block.inc on line 193.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_field_broken::ui_name() should be compatible with views_handler::ui_name($short = false) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_field.inc on line 641.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_sort_broken::ui_name() should be compatible with views_handler::ui_name($short = false) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_sort.inc on line 82.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_filter::options_validate() should be compatible with views_handler::options_validate($form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_filter.inc on line 585.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_filter::options_submit() should be compatible with views_handler::options_submit($form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_filter.inc on line 585.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_filter_broken::ui_name() should be compatible with views_handler::ui_name($short = false) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_filter.inc on line 609.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_filter_boolean_operator::value_validate() should be compatible with views_handler_filter::value_validate($form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_filter_boolean_operator.inc on line 128.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_plugin_style_default::options() should be compatible with views_object::options() in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/plugins/views_plugin_style_default.inc on line 25.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_plugin_row::options_validate() should be compatible with views_plugin::options_validate(&$form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/plugins/views_plugin_row.inc on line 135.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_plugin_row::options_submit() should be compatible with views_plugin::options_submit(&$form, &$form_state) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/plugins/views_plugin_row.inc on line 135.
  • strict warning: Non-static method view::load() should not be called statically in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/views.module on line 843.
  • strict warning: Declaration of content_handler_field::options() should be compatible with views_object::options() in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/cck/includes/views/handlers/content_handler_field.inc on line 208.
  • strict warning: Non-static method view::load() should not be called statically in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/views.module on line 843.
  • strict warning: Non-static method view::load() should not be called statically in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/views.module on line 843.
  • strict warning: Non-static method view::load() should not be called statically in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/views.module on line 843.
  • strict warning: Non-static method view::load() should not be called statically in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/views.module on line 843.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_argument::init() should be compatible with views_handler::init(&$view, $options) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_argument.inc on line 745.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_argument_broken::ui_name() should be compatible with views_handler::ui_name($short = false) in /home/writezil/public_html/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_argument.inc on line 770.

Profiles in Power: Trotsky, by Geoffrey Swain


Today, Good and Bad Kirsty have a somewhat more pleasant task in front of them.  (To refresh your memory, Good Kirsty is my inner historian, the uptight one who deals with my thesis.  Bad Kirsty is my inner reader.  Silly value judgments aside, she’s a little more outspoken than her academic counterpart).
Good Kirsty:  We realised the other day that we’ve been telling you to read Geoffrey Swain’s biography of Trotsky at pretty much every opportunity, but never actually reviewed it properly.  Today seems like the day.
Bad Kirsty:  And we actually get to talk about a book we like!  About time, too.  I was beginning to feel like the Bad News Bear.
GK:  Let’s start with a quick list of the things Swain’s book does not have.  Here’s a major one: there’s no cod psychology.  No attempts to Get Inside the Subject’s Head.  A few rather crisp authorial judgments, yes.  But none of this living-the-character claptrap.
BK:  No ridiculous language either.  There’s not a furrowed brow, a wrung hand, a pale visage or a nervous tic to be seen.
GK:  No lurid imaginings.  No purple passages.
BK:  No embarrassing attempts to be down with the youth.  No tabloid speak.  No questionable pop culture comparisons.
GK:  Of course, the absence of these things doesn’t automatically make for a good book.  But it’s part of the reason this one is so useful, although I am only partly on board with Swain’s overall analysis.
BK:  I feel rather as if all this, together with Swain’s consistent referencing and critical use of sources, shouldn’t even have to be mentioned.  And yet, in the light of recent high profile biographies in Russian history (some of which we have discussed here), these things clearly cannot be taken for granted.
GK:  Grouching aside, though, this really is a very good book and, I believe, an accessible one.  It is published by an academic publisher (Longman) and hasn’t received nearly as much attention as the recent books by Service and Patenaude, but it is a far more reliable introduction to Trotsky than either.  It contains the best short account of Trotsky’s Civil War years I have yet found.   And at 248 pages, it’s concise without omitting too much detail.
BK:  At this point, I must stick my hand up and say that I found the length something of a disadvantage.  The politics of the Russian revolutionary movement both before and after 1917 can be a headache to understand; at first glance there seem to be endless groups and factions (beyond the plain old Bolshevik/Menshevik split, which is not nearly as plain as it may look), allegiances are forever shifting and the terminology can appear impenetrable unless you know your Marx.  Perhaps precisely because of the major strength of this volume – its concentration on the Revolution and Civil War years, the height of Trotsky’s activity – there’s barely room at times to do more than narrate the intra-party arguments, with little context and less reflection.  Chapter 2 (which covers ten years, from 1907-1917) is particularly afflicted.  I have a solid idea of the RSDLP’s dynamics within those years, and even I occasionally had to reach for Trotsky for Beginners.
GK:  Yes, there are times when the narrative almost seems telescoped, and keeping up requires a good deal of concentration.  At the same time, getting to grips with Trotsky and his role in the Revolution does mean understanding the ins and outs of the Russian underground (and later, the intra-party struggle around the succession to Lenin) on at least some basic level.  It’s hard, and frankly it can get boring, but it has to be done.   Personally, I find any kind of linear narrative hard to process when it comes to this stuff; I always end up drawing a diagram or playing with post-it notes.
BK:  Maybe they should give away pads of them with copies of this book.  Although that would presume that the rest of the readership is as nerdy as you.
GK:  Fair point.  But there is a very interesting thread among all the detail about splits and factions and points of theory, concerning Trotsky’s attitude to organisation and ultimately to the whole idea of a revolution, not to mention his opposition to Lenin.  Chapter 2 may be dense and difficult, but there’s a lot of value in there about Trotsky’s political values and the consistency with which he espoused them; while Swain’s stance towards Trotsky has been the subject of heated discussion, Trotsky emerges better here (in my subjective opinion) than he does in his own memoirs, where the pressures of the time required a serious revision of his own history with Lenin.  Swain’s observation that Trotsky “was forced to appear as a second-rate Lenin”, and his sensitive dissection of the consequences of this identity, seem particularly acute to me.
BK:  So you concur with this part of Swain’s analysis, which is a fairly major point.  But not with all of it?
GK:  No.  I have a higher opinion of the innate value of Trotsky’s thought than Swain does (to judge by his statements in his Introduction).  And his analysis of Trotsky’s relationship to Stalin raises a number of questions with me; but I need to do extended research of my own before I can lay out my own thoughts.  I think that the process of interrogating Trotsky’s version of events is absolutely necessary, and I suspect the delineations are indeed less clear than historians often like to believe.  But I don’t think I agree with Swain’s conclusions.  Again, I need to look into this myself before I can really explain why.
BK:  Very mysterious of you.  So I suppose the conclusion is: you may agree with Swain’s argument, or with some of it, or not at all.  But read this book.
GK:  Yes.  Do read this book.  It’s very good, and you’ll have something intelligent to argue with.
BK:  Fair enough.  Rather nice to do a positive review, wasn’t it?
GK:  Yes, it was.  Right then.  Over and out.
Longman, ISBN: 978-0582771901

"To be able to write a play a man must be sensitive, imaginative, naive, gullible, passionate; he must be something of an imbecile, something of a poet, something of a liar, something of a damn fool."
Robert E. Sherwood

Random picks

  • Here's one to send chills through you. The story is in the elision, and I am, for one, thankful that elision is there. Who wants to see the grisliness that occurs? This piece is more harrowing for what we don't see, and for the remains that come back to the surface. Read the story here at Swink.
  • Homonyms-words that sound alike but have different spellings and meanings-can tend to be confusing for writers. This simple quiz will help you to determine which word is appropriate in which context.
  • This is the eighth in Critical Mass's new Second Thoughts series, curated by Daniel Akst. More about this series, and how to submit, here. In a somewhat measured attempt to match the fine example of my 11th grade composition and literature teacher, Mr. Phelan, at Proviso East High, but faced with the clumsy imperfections common to the young and bookish, I had kept my promise to read more widely than the “required reading” list for our class. An effort, I came to see only later, to know broadly and deeply the lay of the land. A sounding or charting, of sorts...
  • Your reviews seed this roundup; please send items, including new about your new publications and recent honors, to NBCCCritics@gmail.com. Make sure to send links that do not require a subscription or username and password. ************************* Steven Kellman reviews The Making of Zombie Wars" by Aleksandar Hemon. C.M. Mayo's "Metaphysical Odyssey Into the Mexican Revolution: Francisco I. Madero and His Secret Book" (Dancing Chiva, 2014) has won the 2015 National Indie Excellence Award for History. Julia M. Klein reviews Richard Thaler's "Misbehaving" for...
  • Every month, Words without Borders reviews editor M. Bartley Seigel shares a handful of recently released or forthcoming titles he’s excited about, books he hopes you’ll agree are worth all our good attentions:   From White Pine Press, Returnings: Poems of Love and Distance by Rafael Alberti, translated from the Spanish by Carolyn Tipton || 158 pages || ISBN 9781935210917 || US$18.00 Says the publisher: “Rafael Alberti was one of the greatest poets of...

Recommended sites

Most recent titles

Fast fact about writing

Writing was developed independently in Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, and among the Maya in Central America. There are some areas where the question as to whether writing was adopted or independently developed is in doubt, as at Easter Island.